Lead Hospitality

Guest Loyalty Strategies Using the Brand Loyalty Matrix

THE IDEA

Guest loyalty is one of the most compelling areas in hospitality—not only because of its direct impact on profitability, but because it reflects a hotel’s ability to build genuine guest relationships. Understanding why guests return, what motivates them emotionally and how to exceed their expectations is central to delivering excellent guest experiences. Whether managing a boutique hotel or a large resort, the challenge is the same: turning every stay into a meaningful memory that inspires loyalty. Data analysis plays a vital role in this process. Hotels cannot improve what they do not measure. By tracking both repeat behaviour and guest attitudes, hospitality professionals can identify patterns and respond with greater precision. The Brand Loyalty Matrix, which combines these two factors, provides a clear framework for guest segmentation and for tailoring strategies that influence how guests perceive a hotel brand. It is not just about the numbers; it is about uncovering the stories behind them and using those insights to design exceptional experiences. Guest loyalty is not exclusive to luxury hotels. Attentive service, a genuine smile and personalised care can make a meaningful difference at any rate level. The matrix shows that every hotel has the potential to move guests towards the true loyalty quadrant—where they not only return, but also become advocates for the brand. That is the real measure of success.

Customer loyalty has always been a subject I am passionate about, not only because of its direct impact on a hotel’s profitability, but because it reflects something much deeper: our ability as hoteliers to create lasting and meaningful connections with people. Loyalty cannot be bought or given away; it must be earned. And it is earned primarily by understanding our guests, adapting to their needs and exceeding their expectations, regardless of the property’s category. In this regard, data analysis has become an invaluable ally in deciphering our customers’ behaviours, desires and emotions. When we talk about loyalty, we are not referring solely to a guest returning to our hotel, but to doing so because they genuinely want to, because they find a special connection with our brand. This is where another of the great pillars that shapes my understanding of hospitality comes into play: the guest experience. This concept is not limited to luxury or exclusivity; it is about offering something exceptional, even in a simple setting, through authenticity, warmth and attention to detail. Service excellence is not about the size of a hotel, but about the scale of its commitment to the guest. A guest does not become loyal by chance. Every interaction, from the first contact to long after their stay, must be intentional and aligned with their expectations. But how can we truly know what our customers value? This is where data analysis becomes an indispensable tool. Data enables us to identify patterns, anticipate needs and personalise every aspect of the experience. However, the most important thing is not collecting data, but knowing how to interpret and use it to make decisions that positively impact the guest. What is fascinating about working on loyalty and the guest experience is that every strategy must be unique. An urban boutique hotel faces different challenges from an all-inclusive resort, yet both can aspire to excellence if they understand their guest and design experiences that leave an emotional imprint. Because, at the end of the day, it is not the hotel category that defines the experience, but the commitment to quality and the effort to connect with those who choose us. Loyalty, data analysis and excellence in the guest experience are themes that, together, can transform a hotel into more than just a place to sleep: into a destination guests want to return to time and again. In this post, we will explore how these concepts are interconnected, how to identify different customer types and how to use the Brand Loyalty Matrix to foster strong, lasting relationships, whether you manage a luxury hotel or a more modest property. True loyalty is not about stars; it is about emotions. The concept of brand loyalty presented in Jacoby and Chestnut’s article “A Two-Dimensional Concept of Brand Loyalty” (1969) has been one of the fundamental foundations for understanding how customers develop relationships with brands. This model suggests that brand loyalty is not a one-dimensional phenomenon, but rather consists of two main axes: attitude and repeat behaviour. Their interaction gives rise to four loyalty patterns that are essential for interpreting how and why consumers maintain or abandon a relationship with a brand. Let us briefly examine them: This is a visual representation of the Brand Loyalty Matrix. It shows the four loyalty patterns according to combinations of attitude (strong or weak) and repeat behaviour (high or low). This matrix can help you identify and segment your customers in order to design specific loyalty strategies.

1. True Loyalty

(Strong attitude + High repeat behaviour)

This pattern represents ideal loyalty, where the customer not only makes repeat purchases, but also has a strong emotional connection with the brand. Customers in this category are active brand advocates, recommending it to others and overlooking alternatives, even if they offer better prices or greater convenience.

      • Examples: A couple who chooses the same hotel every year to celebrate their anniversary, praising the quality of the service and its exclusive atmosphere. A guest who returns to the same hotel every year because they value the quality of service, the design of the facilities and the personalised attention. Even when faced with more affordable options, they continue choosing the same property.
      • Position in the matrix: Top-right quadrant (Strong Attitude + High Repeat Behaviour).

2. Latent Loyalty

(Strong attitude + Low repeat behaviour)

These customers feel a strong affinity with the hotel, but their personal circumstances—location, availability, price, among others—prevent them from returning frequently. Although their repeat behaviour is low, they have a positive disposition towards the brand.

PREMIUM ARTICLE

Continue reading this Premium analysis

Unlock this article individually or choose a subscription that includes Premium access.