The Day I Realized My Hotel Had No Strategy
The great illusion of hotel management: activity without direction
In most hotels, the sense of urgency is constant. The business never stops. Every day, guests arrive and depart, operational issues arise, suppliers are managed, emails are answered, rates are adjusted, online reviews are addressed and multiple departments are overseen. In this context, constant work creates a dangerous illusion: if we are extremely busy, we must be managing the business well. But activity is not strategy. A hotel can have its entire team fully occupied and still not be moving towards any clear competitive positioning. This confusion arises when an organisation operates under a model of reactive management, where problems are solved each day, isolated opportunities are seized and necessary tasks are completed, but no one stops to ask a far more uncomfortable question: why exactly are we doing what we do?
Quiet signs that a hotel has no strategy
The problem with the absence of strategy is that it rarely presents itself as an immediate disaster. Hotels can operate for years without a clear strategic direction. Rooms are sold, the restaurant operates, the team works and the business generates revenue. However, clear symptoms emerge when you look closely.1. Decisions constantly change direction
When there is no robust strategy, decisions depend on the immediate context.
-
- One month, the focus is on attracting groups.
- The following month, the hotel tries to position itself as a boutique property.
- Then it launches a campaign for families.
- Later, it decides to attract corporate events.
Each initiative may seem reasonable on its own, but together they lack coherence. The hotel is constantly moving, but not progressing in any clear direction.
2. The hotel competes on too many fronts at once
One of the most common mistakes in hospitality is trying to be relevant to every possible segment. The result is usually unfocused positioning.
A hotel tries to compete on price with budget hotels, on design appeal with boutique hotels, on service offerings with upper-upscale hotels, and on flexibility for groups, events, romantic breaks and family travel.
The problem is not ambition, but the absence of choice. Strategy requires trade-offs. When a hotel tries to be everything to everyone, it becomes interchangeable.
3. Competitors set the pace of decision-making
One of the clearest indicators of a lack of strategy appears when the internal conversation constantly revolves around what everyone else is doing.
Phrases like these are extremely common:
-
- “The hotel opposite has lowered its rates.”
- “That hotel is offering free breakfast.”
- “Competitors have launched a spa package.”
- “Everyone is on Booking with that promotion.”
When the main reference point for decision-making is the behaviour of other hotels, the business stops leading its own positioning. It starts copying. And copying is not a strategy. It is a reaction.
4. The team works hard, but does not know where the hotel is heading
This is probably the most revealing symptom. In a hotel without a strategy, every department works intensely, but priorities constantly change.
-
- The sales department tries to sell more.
- The front desk tries to manage arrivals more effectively.
- The restaurant tries to increase average spend.
- Marketing tries to improve online visibility.
Everyone is working properly within their own area, but no one can clearly answer one simple question: what kind of hotel are we trying to build?
The uncomfortable moment: when reality becomes clear
The day I understood that my hotel had no strategy did not happen during a financial analysis or after reviewing an occupancy report. It happened while observing a seemingly trivial sequence of decisions. During the same week, we had made three decisions which, taken separately, appeared logical:- we had launched an aggressive promotion to increase low-season occupancy,
- we had approved a significant investment in the food and beverage experience,
- we had discussed a campaign to attract corporate events.
Why many hotels operate without a strategy for years
The main reason is simple: hospitality allows businesses to survive without a strategy for a long time, as long as there is market demand. A hotel can sell rooms thanks to its location, distribution platforms, events at the destination or the tourist season itself. These factors can sustain the business even when its strategic positioning is weak. But the problem emerges when the market changes. When that happens, hotels without a strategy are left exposed.The invisible cost of lacking a strategy
The most serious impact of having no strategy is not an immediate loss of revenue. It is something far subtler and more gradual.1. The hotel becomes interchangeable
If the market perceives that a hotel offers the same as other properties, price ultimately becomes the only differentiating factor. This inevitably leads to rate wars.
2. The team loses operational clarity
When the strategy is unclear, each department interprets priorities differently. The result is an organisation that functions, but without alignment.
3. Investments become fragmented
Without a clear direction, investments are spread across multiple initiatives. The hotel improves many things, but excels at none of them.
4. Positioning never becomes established
A hotel's reputation is built over time. When decisions constantly change, the market never comes to understand what the property truly stands for.
What a hotel without a strategy looks like in real life
Case 1. The hotel that wanted to fill rooms at any cost
A well-located city hotel sees a temporary drop in weekday demand. The immediate response is to open up aggressive discounts across all channels. In the short term, occupancy rises. The problem appears weeks later, when regular corporate guests discover that other guests have paid far less for the same stay, and the hotel begins to erode its perceived value.
My published books
The decision appeared commercially reasonable, but it was not connected to any positioning strategy. The metric of the day was prioritised over the architecture of the business.
Case 2. The hotel that invested without a brand rationale
Another property decides to refurbish its rooftop, then its F&B offering, then its website and finally its rooms. Every investment has value, but none responds to a strategic narrative. The hotel improves, certainly, but it does not build a recognisable identity. It does not become known for anything. It merely adds disconnected improvements.
Case 3. The hotel that pursued every segment
A third hotel tries to attract weekend couples, MICE business, senior groups, families in summer and social events throughout the year. The result is a stretched operation, a confusing value proposition and a commercial message that changes according to the audience. There is no focus, no specialisation and, therefore, no defensible competitive advantage.
The difference between a plan, an objective and a strategy
In hospitality, these three words are often used as if they were interchangeable, but they are not. An objective is an outcome I want to achieve. For example, growing RevPAR by 8%. A plan is a set of actions intended to achieve it. For example, improving pricing, developing upselling and strengthening direct campaigns. Strategy is the logic that explains why those actions make sense in light of the competitive territory I have chosen. A hotel can have objectives and plans without having a strategy. In fact, this happens all the time. The danger is that, from the outside, it looks like a serious and well-organised business. From the inside, however, it is trapped in a continuous sequence of actions with no clear thread running through them.Starting to build a real strategy in a hotel
The first step is not to write a strategy document or organise a brainstorming session. The first step is to accept an uncomfortable truth: strategy begins with difficult choices. It is not about doing more things, but about deciding what to stop doing.Step 1. Define the competitive territory
Every hotel must clearly answer three fundamental questions:
-
- For whom do we truly want to be relevant?
- Which experience do we want to deliver better than anyone else?
- Where will we choose not to compete?
These questions force us to choose. And choosing means making trade-offs.
Step 2. Align operations with the strategy
A strategy only exists if it influences daily operations. This means it must be reflected in pricing policies, experience design, guest selection, product investment and hotel communications.
If strategy does not change specific decisions, it is not a strategy. It is merely rhetoric.
Step 3. Turn strategy into a decision-making criterion
One of strategy's most powerful functions is to serve as a filter. Whenever a new initiative emerges, the key question should be: does this strengthen or weaken the positioning we are building?
If the answer is not clear, it is probably not the right decision.
When I want to assess whether a hotel has a strategy or simply well-organised activity, I like to ask myself the following questions:- Identity: can we clearly explain in one sentence what kind of hotel we want to be?
- Priority guest: do we know which guest profile we are willing to prioritise, even when other segments also generate demand?
- Trade-offs: are we clear about which opportunities we say no to?
- Consistency: do pricing, product, communications and service tell the same story?
- Investment: does every euro invested strengthen a specific advantage, or merely improve isolated aspects?
- Internal culture: does the team understand the hotel's project, or does it simply carry out tasks?
The final paradox: less activity, more direction
The irony of this entire process is that when a hotel finds its real strategy, many things stop being done.- Irrelevant promotions are reduced.
- Segments that do not fit are abandoned.
- Investments that do not reinforce the positioning are ruled out.
Strategy is not about doing more. It is about ensuring that what you do has direction, logic and cumulative value.That day, I realised my hotel had no strategy. Not because it lacked plans, meetings or reports, but because something much more essential was missing: a clear decision about what we wanted to be in the market. Since then, I have learned something that seems obvious, but is forgotten far too often in hospitality: a hotel can work incredibly hard without moving forward. It can sell rooms without building positioning. It can improve its facilities without building competitive advantage. But the moment an organisation clearly decides what it wants to be, everything begins to change. Decisions become simpler. The team understands priorities better. The market starts to recognise an identity. And, for the first time in a long time, the hotel stops moving in every direction and starts moving towards one. That is strategy.
This article ends here. The archive does not.
Lead Hospitality brings together 1200 English articles published since 2018: years of experiences, decisions and lessons you can keep exploring.
What would you like to explore next?
Choose a direction and keep reading around what you want to solve, learn or challenge.